Casino Game Rankings: What They Measure and What They Cannot

Return to the Sezar Casino main page.

Search for a casino game ranking and you will find dozens, all confident, most disagreeing. That is the first clue. If the same releases can be ranked S-tier in one list and mediocre in the next, the lists are not measuring the same thing — and in most cases they are not measuring anything stated at all.

This page does not offer another ranking. It explains what a ranking would have to contain to be checkable, and which two numbers you can look up yourself in about a minute.

Slot information screen showing the theoretical RTP and volatility rating

What most rankings are actually ranking

What a list says What it usually means
“S-tier — incredible feel” The presentation, sound and pacing. Real, subjective, and unrelated to what the game returns
“Massive win potential” The maximum win cap, which says nothing about how likely anything is
“Tested with real money” A session or two. Far too small a sample to separate one game’s maths from another’s
“Best RTP” Occasionally checkable — but only if the list states which RTP configuration it means

None of these are dishonest by themselves. They become dishonest when a subjective ranking is presented as a measurement, and especially when it quotes numbers that cannot be traced to anything published.

A ranking that names games, studios and figures should also let you check them. If you cannot find the game in the studio’s own catalogue, that is the end of the enquiry — and it is worth doing before trusting the rest of the list.

The two numbers that do rank a slot

Theoretical RTP

The share of total stakes a game returns across a very large number of rounds. It is published, certified in a laboratory, and printed in the game’s own information screen. The important detail is that studios ship the same title with more than one RTP configuration — commonly around 96.5%, 95.5% and 94.5% — and the operator chooses which to deploy. The number in the information screen is the one in force where you are.

Volatility

How that return arrives: rarely and in large pieces, or frequently and in small ones. Two games with identical RTP can feel completely different, and volatility is why. High volatility concentrates most of the theoretical return inside a feature round that triggers once every few hundred spins; between those rounds the balance grinds down, and that grind is the design working, not failing.

Everything else in a typical tier list — theme, mechanics, “feel” — is preference. Preference is a legitimate reason to choose a game. It is not a measurement, and it should not be dressed as one.

Why maximum win is the most misleading figure

A published maximum of 50,000× the stake sounds like the headline number, and it is the least informative one on the page. It describes the extreme tail of the distribution without saying anything about its likelihood, and reaching it usually requires a specific combination inside a feature round that most players will never trigger.

A game capped at 5,000× with a higher RTP and lower volatility will, over any realistic number of sessions, treat a bankroll better than one capped at 50,000×. The cap sells the game; the other two numbers describe it.

A comparison you can actually run

  1. Open the game and press the information or paytable button.
  2. Read the line beginning “theoretical RTP”. Note it — that is the configuration on this site, not the studio’s headline.
  3. Find the volatility rating in the same screen.
  4. If there is a bonus buy, check whether it lists a separate RTP. It often does, and it is often different.
  5. Repeat for the second game. The comparison is now between two published numbers rather than two opinions.

For house edge on table games and side bets, the same principle applies and the figures are collected publicly — Wizard of Odds is the long-standing reference. The mechanics behind the individual slot features are covered in how modern slot mechanics work.

Frequently asked questions

Are game tier lists reliable?

Rarely, because what is being ranked usually goes unstated. A list built on published RTP and volatility is checkable; one built on how a session felt is not.

What two numbers rank a slot?

Theoretical RTP and volatility, both printed in the game’s own information screen.

Does a higher maximum win mean a better game?

No. It describes the extreme tail of the distribution, not its shape or likelihood.

Why does the same game show different RTP at different casinos?

Studios ship several configurations and the operator deploys one. The figure in force is in the information screen.

How do I compare two games quickly?

Read both information screens: theoretical RTP, volatility, and any separate RTP on the bonus buy.

Get Bonus